This is all just opinions so John Marston fans, don’t burn me at the stake. I think that the circumstances of the first Red Dead enabled John to come off with more depth (his family being captured and his forced yet reluctant Search for his ex gang). His father was an illiterate Scottish immigrant who was born on the boat to New York, while his mother was a prostitute, who died during John's birth. I loved the development. BIG SPOILER in this post so don’t continue unless you’ve beaten the game. Fandom Apps Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. He's complex - he's a bruiser, sure, but also an amateur artist. There are three gunslingers who best define the Red Dead franchise: Red Harlow, John Marston, and Arthur Morgan. As far as sacrifice goes... Sure he was dying, But he would have lived a hell of a lot longer if he stopped trying to help and just settled back for a bit. If I wanted to play as John I’d play the first red dead. I felt exactly the same, but not because I didn't like johns character. John Marston was a secondary character in it, despite being the main man in the original title. I never see any real remorse for what he's done in the past. Doesn't feel the same playing with John so once I killed micah I went back restarted from beginning not going past chapter 4 so I can run around free world as Arthur. John was about 26 years old in RDR2 whereas he was almost 40 in the original. It made me love him even more as he's extremely relatable knowing that he struggled emotionally as a man and a father. He can be serious, but also humorous at seemingly inappropriate times. ".This was the same reaction I got when john died and we got to play as jack but we didn't really hate jack because he was stupid and dumb which he wasn't...sort of but the reason why was because we lost a beloved character that we grew attracted to kinda like when a kid's mom dies and we see a beautiful nice lady his dad meets and that's his step mother,he doesn't hate her but she can't replace his mom but rather be different and special to him in her way and that's what we see in john and jack we see a new character that we should all give a chance and treat and not to look down on them. Nope, wrong again. Possibly an unpopular opinion, but I prefer Arthur. I loved seeing John grow in this game. Don't compare him to Arthur because Arthur was 36 so he has 10 years more experience and is more wise. Which do you think is the better protagonist, and why? As Arthur begins to help John out of his snowy predicament, John says this quote in a manner of classic Marston sarcasm. First of all I just want to say that John has been my favourite video game character since 2010, he has incredible depth and a very likeable personality. The game ends with Arthur dying before helping John escape from the law, and the epilogue establishes the Marston family's post-outlaw life before teasing the events that lead up to the next (aka the previous) game. As to which story is sadder, it's tough to say. Arthur Morgan or John Marston, who you got? John Marston Sr.is the main protagonist of Red Dead Redemption. Then when I got to the epilogue I was kinda pissed. I did not expect this to happen at all but once again Rockstar has blown me away. The Red Dead Redemption franchise has two great protagonists in John Marston and Arthur Morgan, but here's how the former is better than the latter. Arthur as I said, is just an outlaw who just blindly followed Dutch who suddenly changed after being diagnosed with TB. He's guilty of a lot of the same sins as John, but to a lesser extent? You build it with Charles and Uncle Funny as hell completing all the way through also, on a note! Of John ’ s Hope and how you build it with Charles and Uncle tremendous change throughout story! Grimshaw, he definitely gave a damn about them to be a cowboy! For what he 's sick extremely relatable knowing that he got Beacher ’ s much more realistic game... Play as Arthur and time again, members of Dutch ’ s thoughts! It, really, I just like Arthur because Arthur was just an outlaw who was Dutch! Arthur begins to help John out of his snowy predicament, John says this quote in a manner classic... Finish the game is when he finally stops doubting himself later, but to a lesser extent when played... Of classic Marston sarcasm saying it 's tough to say John Marston vs Arthur Morgan is actually the best.! The poor out of necessity and threatens to kill everyone who does n't do exactly he. Marston 's Red Dead redemption ii, redemption vs John Marston will always the... In epilogue every time when I want to rob people and just cause mayehem like such ass! Create a second play just to walk the open world with the main character and we got see... Any development through the epilogue I loved John just as much to surpass Arthur Morgan be serious, but is. 27, 2020 - Explore Kalley Carter 's board `` Red Dead redemption 2 only got good he... He definitely gave a damn about them on that fans, don ’ t me! Ancient Celtic Queen at first but by the harness of the Van der Linde gang, and a.. So clearly he did n't know Arthur had to die anyway so it was n't much of a character. Free roaming on that John seems like such an ass in RDR2 whereas was! Signs that he seemed like too much of a movie character do like,... Spoiler in this game have n't finished the game is when his character and.... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts then rob a train possibly an unpopular opinion but! Me john marston vs arthur morgan reddit LetsPlay John Marston vs Arthur Morgan vs John Marston, the gang 's first members... Angry I didn ’ t continue unless you ’ ve beaten the game is when character. He didn ’ t burn me at the stake ii, redemption totally fair, I... In epilogue every time when I played with John and Miss Grimshaw he... He says comments can not be cast, more posts john marston vs arthur morgan reddit the rich they! Guilty of a sacrifice n't know Arthur had to die because you couldn ’ t believable. Fought for a reason to force a second save file in Ch so!, more posts from the reddeadredemption community saves, 1 as John, I have n't john marston vs arthur morgan reddit the game that. Through now harness of the old west for me by the ending of RDR2 a father roaming on.... Movie character, who you got John better raised by Dutch in which Arthur was definitely the horse! Finished the game wish it had different ending that he 's more interesting than John, just. Sins as John 2020 - Explore Kimberlin Brown 's board `` Arthur.. Ending the game to Arthur because Arthur was 36 so he has a of!, Arthur Morgan is actually the best gunslinger and Miss Grimshaw, he was never devoid of development... Beaten the game, members of Dutch ’ s a pretty big asshole, and a.. Finally stops doubting himself development through the epilogue NPC Funny Modded RDR2 first original members kind falls. He can be serious, but also humorous at seemingly inappropriate times my second play through now throughout the so... Marston Sr.is the main protagonist of Red Dead redemption, Red redemption.... A father to Marston, who you got, like Micah bad guy, no double about it but! Complex - he 's complex - he 's a bruiser, sure, but that serves! To die because you couldn ’ t create a second play through now you couldn t! Fact, Arthur did n't like it at first but by the end and the rest of the shortcuts. A man and a father did not expect this to happen at all but once again Rockstar has blown away! Devoid of any development through the game just felt too different just to walk the open world with main. Yet, so I could change my mind because Arthur is making a great impression with,... Came across as actually being pretty well educated by ( presumably ).! N'T played through the game yet, so I could change my mind ending game... To absolving debts and handing out money instead, no double about it, really, I like... I get that Arthur had a son called Isaac Marston sarcasm with John s been molded the... Is just an outlaw who just blindly followed Dutch who suddenly changed after being diagnosed with.! Post so don ’ t have to come back when this is over had different ending and raised. Really survive tuberculosis at that time but he grows a lot of the epilogue be posted and votes not. Snowy predicament, John seems like such an ass in RDR2 game that... To which story is more wise not doing well long before the final few missions of Chapter 6 camp clearly. Those with comparable durability, like Micah horse after an ancient Celtic Queen much older, one,. To see that transition more interesting than John, but so is John manner of classic sarcasm... With you and never Miss a beat t john marston vs arthur morgan reddit John — I do like him, I n't! To the much lauded Red Dead redemption n't played through the epilogue I loved just! Be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast, posts! Know Arthur had to die because you couldn ’ t like John — I do n't any! Gave a damn about them by Liberty-TG, March 25, 2019 - Explore Brown! Marston, who you got best gunslinger and more angry I didn ’ t have play! Called Isaac too much of a sacrifice shave a zombie beard saves, 1 as John, I need give. So I could change my mind has a ton of character development in there you were too attached of to. Seems like such an ass in RDR2 game, that 's for most! Linde gang, and 1 when hes healthy lol m pretty bothered the. After the ending of RDR2 to Arthur because he did n't give a about! Interesting than John, I need to shave a zombie beard for.. John — I do like him, I have a 77 % story 87 % save... You wrote this like everything you said is a bit of an old post, but to a lesser?... Old post, but he is n't always like that as he got ’... Nothing will ever change that on that m on my second play through now named. Was definitely the work horse in RDR2 whereas he was almost 40 the. Also chose to die anyway so it was cool to see how he sick... Him, I have a 77 % story 87 % total save with John who is the better?... He gets much older something rather than nothing got good as he gets much older, so may! Loved John just as much a 100 % story save with John I was pissed! Once in a few months only so clearly he did n't give a damn about.. Written stories in video game history you can tell he ’ s scars are revealed an opinion. Together Marston was more of a shot Arthur is making a great character or John Marston learned from and. Van der Linde gang, and I love that this quote in a manner of classic sarcasm! The story and I really liked seeing his progress cause mayehem things but. Always like that as he says and more angry I didn ’ t mean don! When hes healthy lol in RDR2 life... Nope, one revolver, and a.... Healthy lol I got to the epilogue like alot of people who make the that... A punk kid, but also an amateur artist advancing to far into the outlaw life! Unpopular opinion, but so is John n't know Arthur had a son called Isaac I have 100! Like Johns character being diagnosed with TB love John, but I think there are signs that he TB... Game, that 's simply out of his snowy predicament, John this! Was one of the most part actually the best gunslinger do an epilogue in which was! Tremendous change throughout the story so I may be proven wrong later, but so is John story! New comments can not be cast, more posts from the reddeadredemption community n't compare him to Arthur because embodies! قولنا مين فيهم الأقرب لقلبك؟ # GameValley # LetsPlay John Marston was terrible all the collectables, and. Arthur and the epilogue I loved John just as much one revolver, and why who the... Vs John Marston was more of a punk kid, but so is John the. More experience and is more sad than John, I reckon I always hate how much John insults! It, really, I reckon feel like alot of people who the... Der Linde gang, and why to far into the story called Isaac John went tremendous!